Edit ModuleShow Tags

10 Must-Try San Diego Desserts of 2018

Chocolate, fruit-forward, caramel-laced, and more—here are the 10 sweet treats that caught our eye this year


1. Warm Chocolate Brownie at Bankers Hill Bar + Restaurant

We devoted our November 2018 issue to desserts, so we’d be remiss not to kick things off with our cover star: Bankers Hill Bar + Restaurant’s warm chocolate brownie topped with espresso-Bailey’s ice cream and pretzel crumbles. “This dish really takes me back to my childhood,” says Chef de Cuisine Tyler Nollenberger. “When you’re 10 years old, what’s better than a brownie and ice cream? And making the ice cream with Bailey’s? Well, that appeals to my adult side.”


2. Chino Farms Strawberries at George’s California Modern

Seasonality is a key component of chef Trey Foshee’s menu at George’s at the Cove in La Jolla, and that ethos spills over to their desserts, too. Pastry Chef Aly Lang created this multi-textural ode to berries—a hibiscus-infused jelly paired with sliced strawberries, an aerated frozen strawberry yogurt, chilled strawberry-rhubarb consommé, crispy dehydrated strawberry meringue pieces, and Tajín, the staple Mexican chili-lime seasoning. “The different textures and temperatures are what make this dish most interesting to me,” she says, “but the real star is how amazing Chino Farms strawberries are as-is, unaltered.”


3. Green apple cotton candy at Pisco Rotisserie & Cevicheria

When Troy Johnson reviewed this Peruvian restaurant, he called Pisco’s cotton candy “ridiculous, delicious, odd” and “a must to order for anyone under 10 at your table—or just for anyone.” After plates of ceviche, causitas, and ají de gallina—not to mention multiple orders of pisco sours—make sure to order this towering nod to childhood nostalgia.


4. Chocolate verrine at Born & Raised

Yes, this Little Italy restaurant from CH Projects, which cost $6.5 million to build, is all about the dry-aged steaks and tableside preparations. But don’t miss out on their desserts, like this chocolate verrine with 70-percent dark chocolate, coffee marshmallow, cacao nib crumble, marzipan cake, and sugared cranberry. As critic Troy Johnson says, “It’s sweet, tart, crispy, silky, moussey, a bit of everything that ends in ‘yes.’”


5. The Lemon at 1500 Ocean

This playful plate was so good it appeared in both our September Sweet Spot column and our November 2018 desserts cover story. At 1500 Ocean, the upscale restaurant at Hotel del Coronado, chef Patrick Ponsaty wanted to show diners that French food can be sophisticated and fun at the same time. Inside is a juicy center of poached Meyer lemon pieces, chocolate mint, and tropical finger lime, as well a yuzu-spiked chocolate. Once that’s all frozen, it’s coated in white chocolate and natural yellow coloring with a spray of gold dust.


6. Seasonal cream buns at Wayfarer Bread & Pastry

What started as a Kickstarter campaign has turned into a wildly popular bakery in Bird Rock that’s been written up in Sunset magazine, The New York Times, and of course, San Diego Magazine. We included Pastry Chef Crystal White’s seasonal cream buns in our desserts issue, but it’s hard to pick a favorite from her stable of sweets. We also love her strawberry-pistachio croissants, gourmet toasts, and breakfast sandwiches with housemade English muffins.


7. Plantain semifreddo at El Jardín

“It’s a hilarious, minimalistic, almost punk idea in today’s world of Instagram plating with edible flowers and gold leaf.” That’s how food critic Troy Johnson describes the plantain semifreddo at the Liberty Station restaurant led by Top Chef and Bracero alum Claudette Zepeda-Wilkins. It’s encircled by chocolate fudge cake swirls, ancho chile, Oaxacan chocolate jam, and criollo cacao nibs.


8. Aileen Gateau at Dessertier

This berry sponge cake isn’t new, but this year we got to hear the story behind Michele Coulon’s sweet ode to her grandmother. As she shared in our November 2018 issue, her grandmother Aileen imparted her own sweet tooth to Coulon, so the pastry chef made this cake in her honor. “She got me to make that cake for her. It’s really special to me,” Coulon says. “We have such fond memories of those grandparents. They were the ultimate. My parents were super, super, super strict. No sugar at all. If it was your birthday, you got a little. But my grandparents let us have candy!”


9. Passionfruit butter cake at Red O

Butter is a key component in most desserts; in this case, it’s the star. The UTC restaurant serves this butter cake with strawberries, passion fruit custard, coconut crumble, and coconut ice cream. It’s soft, smooth, with the right amount of tang from the fruit.


10. Pear soufflé at Herb & Wood

Executive Pastry Chef Adrian Mendoza honed his skills at the two Michelin-starred Spago in Beverly Hills before landing in San Diego at Brian Malarkey’s Little Italy restaurant. Here, he turns out buttery croissants, crepe cakes, and more, but it’s his soufflés that are a star. Flavors rotate seasonally—you’ll find pear on the current menu—and the process requires the utmost skill. “If you underwhip, it won’t rise as high, but if you overwhip, the soufflé will rise tall then deflate within seconds,” Mendoza says. “If it’s whipped just right, the soufflé has a three-to-five-minute window before it starts descending.”

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »Related Stories

22 Ways to Celebrate Halloween in San Diego This Year

Plan a night (at least) of trick-or-treating, sipping, dancing, and eating this spooky season.

The SoCal (Social Calendar!)

From black-tie galas to costumed 5Ks, these events will keep your social calendar full—and you feeling good

Eppig Brewing Moves to Vista

The three-year-old brewery expands brewing capacity and footprint at new North County headquarters
Edit Module

Subscribe to the Blog

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags


The Vape Debate

Two Scripps doctors weigh in on this dangerous trend

Kaiser Permanente San Diego Makes Life Easier

Kaiser Permanente brings high quality, affordable care to San Diegans when and where they need it
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. The Best of San Diego 2019
    Our annual compilation of everything delicious, cool, and Instagrammable in San Diego (and Baja!)
  2. The Problem With Bright Red Tuna
    Many Americans still think bright red tuna means it’s fresher (it’s not)
  3. First Look: Animae
    Puffer Malarkey Restaurants unveil 5.5 million-dollar pan-Asian concept
  4. Jason Mraz and his Historic Coffee Bean
    The singer and Bird Rock Coffee Roasters unveil the first California-grown Geisha coffee
  5. Morning Glory Is a Millennial Wonderland
    The Little Italy restaurant may finally break San Diego's aversion to brunch
  6. A Deep Dive into the San Diego Fishing Industry
    A $2 billion project is poised to revive San Diego’s commercial fishing industry
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module