Almond
Suitable as a coffee creamer, it has surged in popularity—at a price. Almonds require staggering amounts of water (15 gallons to produce just 16 almonds, according to the New York Times), so drink responsibly.
Where to find it: Pannikin Coffee & Tea, Refill Cafe, Parakeet Cafe
Coconut
“It gives you the closest creaminess because it has fat,” Gray-Meisner says of this milk made with shredded coconut meat.
Where to find it: James Coffee Co., Cafe Gratitude, Lofty Coffee Co.
Oat
This grain-based alternative yields a creamy, frothy texture ideal for blended espresso drinks.
Where to find it: Achilles Coffee Roasters, Dark Horse Coffee Roasters
Soy
It’s high in protein and calcium, but Gray-Meisner says this milk blended from hulled soybeans has fallen off the radar for a reason: There are links to increased risk of breast cancer and thyroid issues.
Where to find it: All over
Hemp
Beyond being a fast-growing crop with a low carbon footprint, hemp is also packed with omega-3 fatty acids, important for brain health.
Where to find it: Seven Seas Roasting Co., Lazy Hummingbird
Cashew
Expect to see this creamy, fatty milk on more menus. And if the pulp’s not strained, expect the same nutrition as whole cashews: good fats, vitamins B and E, minerals, protein, and fiber.
Where to find it: Good on Ya, Coffee Cycle