Anne Watson
Browse this year’s list by category:
Overall | Atmosphere | Specific Dishes | Specific Cuisines | Drinks
From the Critic Troy Johnson
Welcome to the Spotlight
We’re next.
For decades, the national food media hunkered in the safe zones. Namely, New York, Chicago, and San Francisco. Those cities, our anthills of art and commerce, provided enough world-class dishes, cocktails, and rags-to-Michelin stories to fill the pages and posts. Sure, food media would make the occasional jaunt to exotic locales—”Tulum is the New Lima!”—but they treated secondary US markets as less-exciting siblings. Too familiar to be discovered, too not–New York to justify the travel budget.
To get recognition for their tireless work, most top-tier chefs lived and worked in the “major three.”
And now those years are over. Regional and social media have filled the holes, illuminated the cracks. Meccas were made of Austin, Portland, Charleston, Oakland, and Houston. Thanks to apps like Instagram and pubs like San Diego Magazine being online and globally readable, chefs have realized the circus isn’t the only place with a spotlight.
That’s why Richard Blais lives here, and why he was able to lure Anthony Wells from Per Se to Juniper and Ivy. That’s why Michelin-starred brothers recently moved from Italy to open Il Dandy in Bankers Hill. And why Top Chef runner-up and Jean-Georges vet Angelo Sosa chose Encinitas for his Death by Tequila. Why chefs like Trey Foshee, Jason Knibb, Claudette Zepeda- Wilkins, Carl Schroeder, and William Bradley are now resurfacing in national headlines.
The titans of media have noticed, and are adjusting. The New York Times recently allocated a food critic for our region (two San Diego restaurants have made the pages). Local chefs are trading rumors about the whereabouts of Michelin Guide critics, who are in town and looking for places to hang their stars.
The spotlight is circling our city. The best thing is that its fringes will illuminate our indies. The gems run on very little budget by locals who are passionate about food, drink, and the art of hospitality. Blue Water Seafood. Las Cuatro Milpas. Fort Oak. Grand Ole BBQ. Izakaya Masa. Dark Horse Roasters. Le Parfait Paris. Maestoso. Kindred. Special places created in the shadows, serving hustle and grit. You’ll see all of these names in my critic’s picks for our annual Best Restaurants feature.
As someone who’s covered San Diego’s restaurant scene for 12 years, I cheer the international media’s arrival. Welcome to a city with the highest number of small farms in the US, where the growing seasons are obscenely long and the produce infinitely better. Welcome to a city where the restaurants finally do those farms justice. A city that once deserved your omission, and now equally deserves your attention.
Overall
Anne Watson
Best of the Best Fancy
Critic’s Pick: Juniper and Ivy
Readers’ Pick: Juniper and Ivy
Runner-up: Born & Raised
Best of the Best Casual
Critic’s Pick: Grand Ole BBQ y Asado, (Flinn Springs)
Readers’ Pick: The Crack Shack
Runner-up: Whisknladle
Best New Restaurant
Critic’s Pick: Fort Oak
Readers’ Pick: Death by Tequila
Runner-up: Jeune et Jolie
Best Chef
Critic’s Pick: Carl Schroeder (Market)
Readers’ Pick: Ryan Johnston (Catania)
Runner-up: Brad Wise (Trust, Fort Oak)
Best Service
Critic’s Pick: Trust
Readers’ Pick: RoVino
Runner-up: Solare Ristorante
Best Hotel Restaurant
Critic’s Pick: Nine-Ten
Readers’ Pick: Nine-Ten
Runner-up: Lionfish
Best Restaurant in Baja
Critic’s Pick: Animalón
Readers’ Pick: Oryx Capital
Runner-up: Deckman’s en el Mogor
Best Happy Hour
Critic’s Pick: Bankers Hill Bar + Restaurant
Readers’ Pick: Herringbone
Runner-up: Bub’s at the Ballpark
Best Bar Menu
Critic’s Pick: Tiger!Tiger!
Readers’ Pick: Starlite
Runner-up: Death by Tequila
Best Late-Night Menu
Critic’s Pick: Starlite
Readers’ Pick: Starlite
Runner-up: Royale
Best Indulgent Eats
Critic’s Pick: The Crack Shack
Readers’ Pick: The Crack Shack
Runner-up: Extraordinary Desserts and Pop Pie Co. (tie)
Best Cheap Eats
Critic’s Pick: The Porchetta Shack
Readers’ Pick: The Kebab Shop
Runner-up: The Crack Shack
Best Caterer
Critic’s Pick: Wild Thyme
Readers’ Pick: Kitchens for Good
Runner-up: Miho Catering
Best Buffet
Critic’s Pick: Provisional Kitchen
Readers’ Pick: Barona Casino
Runner-up: Viejas Casino
Best Healthy Eats
Critic’s Pick: Tahini
Readers’ Pick: Everbowl
Runner-up: Café Gratitude
Best Gluten-Free Menu
Critic’s Pick: Civico 1845
Readers’ Pick: True Food Kitchen
Runner-up: Frost Me Gourmet
Best Vegetarian
Critic’s Pick: Kindred
Readers’ Pick: Royal India
Runner-up: Café Gratitude
Best Bakery
Critic’s Pick: Panchita’s
Readers’ Pick: Edelweiss
Runner-up: Wayfarer
Best Breakfast/ Brunch
Critic’s Pick: Herb & Eatery
Readers’ Pick: Breakfast Republic
Runner-up: Snooze, an A.M. Eatery
Best Taco Shop
Critic’s Pick: Lola 55
Readers’ Pick: Lucha Libre
Runner-up: The Taco Stand
Best Barbecue
Critic’s Pick: Grand Ole BBQ y Asado
Readers’ Pick: Phil’s BBQ
Runner-up: Grand Ole BBQ y Asado
Best Steakhouse
Critic’s Pick: Cowboy Star
Readers’ Pick: Cowboy Star
Runner-up: Born & Raised
Best Seafood
Critic’s Pick: Blue Water Seafood
Readers’ Pick: Truluck’s
Runner-up: Ironside
Best Desserts
Critic’s Pick: Le Parfait Paris
Readers’ Pick: Extraordinary Desserts
Runner-up: Snoice
Best Cheese Program
Critic’s Pick: Venissimo
Readers’ Pick: Venissimo
Runner-up: The Patio Group
Best Farmers’ Market Food Vendor
Critic’s Pick: Prager Brothers Artisan Breads
Readers’ Pick: Bitchin’ Sauce
Runner-up: Gihon Ethiopian Kitchen
Best Restaurant Merch
Critic’s Pick: Urban Kitchen Group
Readers’ Pick: Gravity Heights
Runner-up: El Chingon
Best Restaurant Instagram Feed
Critic’s Pick: Soda & Swine
Readers’ Pick: S3 Coffee Bar
Runner-up: Cucina Urbana
Atmosphere
Anne Watson
Best Design
Critic’s Pick: Realm of the 52 Remedies
Readers’ Pick: Born & Raised
Runner-up: Herringbone
Best View (Urban)
Critic’s Pick: Mister A’s
Readers’ Pick: Mister A’s
Runner-up: The Nolen
Best View (Water)
Critic’s Pick: Cusp
Readers’ Pick: Coasterra
Runner-up: George’s at the Cove
Best Kid-Friendly Restaurant
Critic’s Pick: Station Tavern & Burgers
Readers’ Pick: Corvette Diner
Runner-up: Waypoint Public
Best Pet-Friendly Restaurant
Critic’s Pick: Queenstown Public
Readers’ Pick: Queenstown Public
Runner-up: The Patio Group
Best Special Occasion
Critic’s Pick: George’s California Modern
Readers’ Pick: Royal Banquet
Runner-up: Truluck’s
Best Outdoor Patio
Critic’s Pick: Jaynes Gastropub
Readers’ Pick: Rustic Root
Runner-up: George’s at the Cove
Best Tasting Room
Critic’s Pick: Carruth Cellars
Readers’ Pick: Carruth Cellars
Runner-up: Ballast Point
Best Date Spot
Critic’s Pick: Alexander’s
Readers’ Pick: Catania
Runner-up: Jeune et Jolie
Best Diner
Critic’s Pick: El Carrito
Readers’ Pick: Studio Diner
Runner-up: Corvette Diner
Best Place to Watch the Game
Critic’s Pick: Barleymash
Readers’ Pick: Barleymash
Runner-up: Nolita Hall
Best Restaurant for Big Groups
Critic’s Pick: Stone World Bistro & Gardens
Readers’ Pick: Mezé Greek Fusion
Runner-up: Campfire
Best Restaurant at Petco Park
Critic’s Pick: Seaside Market
Readers’ Pick: Phil’s BBQ
Runner-up: Hodad’s
Best Business Lunch
Critic’s Pick: Grant Grill
Readers’ Pick: Searsucker
Runner-up: Mister A’s
Specific Dishes
Anne Watson
Best Burger
Critic’s Pick: Rocky’s Crown Pub
Readers’ Pick: Royale
Runner-up: Rocky’s Crown Pub
Best Veggie Burger
Critic’s Pick: Peace Pies
Readers’ Pick: Royale
Runner-up: Burger Lounge
Best Salad
Critic’s Pick: Whisknladle
Readers’ Pick: Urban Plates
Runner-up: Tender Greens
Best Sandwich
Critic’s Pick: The Grill at Torrey Pines
Readers’ Pick: Board & Brew
Runner-up: Mona Lisa
Best Taco
Critic’s Pick: ¡Salud!
Readers’ Pick: Puesto
Runner-up: The Taco Stand
Best Fish Taco
Critic’s Pick: Galaxy Taco
Readers’ Pick: Rubio’s
Runner-up: Brigantine
Best Chips and Salsa
Critic’s Pick: Chuy’s Taco Shop
Readers’ Pick: Puesto
Runner-up: Miguel’s Cocina
Best Chilaquiles
Critic’s Pick: Super Cocina
Readers’ Pick: Whisknladle
Runner-up: Cocina 35
Best Burrito
Critic’s Pick: Las Cuatro Milpas
Readers’ Pick: Lucha Libre
Runner-up: El Chingon
Best Fries
Critic’s Pick: The Taco Stand
Readers’ Pick: The Kebab Shop
Runner-up: The Crack Shack
Best Mac ’n’ Cheese
Critic’s Pick: Mister A’s
Readers’ Pick: Mezé Greek Fusion
Runner-up: Barleymash
Best Pizza
Critic’s Pick: Buona Forchetta
Readers’ Pick: Bronx Pizza
Runner-up: Buona Forchetta
Best Chicken Wings
Critic’s Pick: OB Noodle House
Readers’ Pick: Epic Wings N Things
Runner-up: Dirty Birds
Best Sushi
Critic’s Pick: Wrench & Rodent Seabasstropub
Readers’ Pick: Sushi Lounge
Runner-up: Sushi Ota
Best Dumplings
Critic’s Pick: Facing East
Readers’ Pick: Dumpling Inn
Runner-up: Din Tai Fung
Best Ramen
Critic’s Pick: Izakaya Masa
Readers’ Pick: Tajima
Runner-up: Underbelly
Best Pho
Critic’s Pick: Pho Hoa
Readers’ Pick: Pho Ca Dao
Runner-up: Phuong Trang
Best Donut
Critic’s Pick: Donut Touch
Readers’ Pick: Donut Bar
Runner-up: VG Donut & Bakery
Best Ice Cream
Critic’s Pick: Stella Jean’s
Readers’ Pick: Salt & Straw
Runner-up: An’s Dry Cleaning
Specific Cuisine
Anne Watson
Best Italian
Critic’s Pick: Maestoso
Readers’ Pick: Solare Ristorante
Runner-up: RoVino
Best French
Critic’s Pick: Addison
Readers’ Pick: Jeune et Jolie
Runner-up: The French Gourmet
Best Mexican
Critic’s Pick: El Jardín
Readers’ Pick: Death by Tequila
Runner-up: Las Cuatro Milpas
Best Greek
Critic’s Pick: Mezé Greek Fusion
Readers’ Pick: Mezé Greek Fusion
Runner-up: Luna Grill
Best Spanish
Critic’s Pick: Costa Brava
Readers’ Pick: Costa Brava
Runner-up: Café Sevilla
Best Chinese
Critic’s Pick: Minh Ky
Readers’ Pick: Mandarin Wok
Runner-up: Chin’s Szechwan
Best Japanese
Critic’s Pick: Yakyudori
Readers’ Pick: Kokoro
Runner-up: Umami Japanese
Best Thai
Critic’s Pick: Plumeria
Readers’ Pick: Bahn Thai
Runner-up: Lotus Thai
Best Asian Fusion
Critic’s Pick: Dija Mara
Readers’ Pick: Chiko
Runner-up: Monkey King
Best Vietnamese
Critic’s Pick: Phuong Trang
Readers’ Pick: Phuong Trang
Runner-up: Shank & Bone
Best Korean
Critic’s Pick: Buga Korean BBQ
Readers’ Pick: Chiko
Runner-up: Manna Korean BBQ
Best Filipino
Critic’s Pick: Fredcel Lumpias
Readers’ Pick: Tita’s Kitchenette
Runner-up: Manila Sunset
Best Peruvian
Critic’s Pick: Panca
Readers’ Pick: Café Secret
Runner-up: Panca
Best Southern
Critic’s Pick: The Flying Pig
Readers’ Pick: Bud’s Louisiana Cafe
Runner-up: StreetCar Merchants
Best Indian
Critic’s Pick: Masala Street
Readers’ Pick: Royal India
Runner-up: Taste of the Himalayas
Best Ethiopian
Critic’s Pick: Muzita
Readers’ Pick: Muzita
Runner-up: Awash
Best Russian
Critic’s Pick: Pomegranate
Readers’ Pick: Pomegranate
Runner-up: Pushkin
Best Middle Eastern
Critic’s Pick: The Kebab Shop
Readers’ Pick: The Kebab Shop
Runner-up: Bandar
Drinks
Anne Watson
Best Wine List
Critic’s Pick: Addison
Readers’ Pick: Solare Ristorante
Runner-up: RoVino
Best Winery
Critic’s Pick: Gianni Buonomo Vintners
Readers’ Pick: Gianni Buonomo Vintners
Runner-up: Carruth Cellars
Best Wine Bar
Critic’s Pick: Wet Stone
Readers’ Pick: Gianni Buonomo Vintners
Runner-up: RoVino
Best New Brewery
Critic’s Pick: Gravity Heights
Readers’ Pick: Gravity Heights
Runner-up: Kairoa
Best Brewery
Critic’s Pick: Alesmith
Readers’ Pick: Stone Brewing Co.
Runner-up: Modern Times
Best Brewpub
Critic’s Pick: Blind Lady Ale House
Readers’ Pick: Gravity Heights
Runner-up: Waypoint Public
Best Distillery
Critic’s Pick: You & Yours
Readers’ Pick: You & Yours
Runner-up: Cutwater Spirits
Best Cocktails
Critic’s Pick: Polite Provisions
Readers’ Pick: Royale
Runner-up: Polite Provisions
Best Mocktails
Critic’s Pick: False Idol
Readers’ Pick: Campfire
Runner-up: Jeune et Jolie
Best Margarita
Critic’s Pick: Cantina Mayahuel
Readers’ Pick: Puesto
Runner-up: Death by Tequila
Best Bloody Mary
Critic’s Pick: The Med (La Valencia)
Readers’ Pick: Farmer’s Table
Runner-up: Small Bar
Best Bottomless Mimosa
Critic’s Pick: Cafe 21
Readers’ Pick: Searsucker
Runner-up: The Duck Dive
Best Coffee
Critic’s Pick: Dark Horse
Readers’ Pick: S3 Coffee Bar
Runner-up: Dark Horse
Best Juice Bar
Critic’s Pick: Northside Shack
Readers’ Pick: Nekter
Runner-up: Choice Juicery
Best Kombucha
Critic’s Pick: Boochcraft
Readers’ Pick: Mighty Booch and JuneShine (tie)
Runner-up: Powerhaus Pizza
Best Matcha
Critic’s Pick: Deja Brew
Readers’ Pick: Holy Matcha
Runner-up: S3 Coffee Bar
Best Dive Bar
Critic’s Pick: Aero Club
Readers’ Pick: Waterfront
Runner-up: High Dive