Ready to know more about San Diego?

Subscribe

The Story Behind San Diego’s Most Legendary Cocktail

Shelter Island’s Bali Hai restaurant celebrates 70 years of making Mai Tais and keeping the city’s tiki culture alive and well
San Diego's most popular cocktail featuring the Mai Tai at restaurant Bali Hai in Shelter Island
Courtesy of Bali Hai

In this week’s episode, we dive into the history of San Diego’s iconic Bali Hai, a restaurant that’s been a cornerstone of the city’s tiki culture for 70 years. Our guests are the family who’s been running the show since the beginning: Larry and Suzie Baumann and their son Tommy who have been pouring more Mai Tais than anyone in town—and making sure you don’t have more than two in one sitting. (For real, they’ll cut you off.)

When we began reminiscing, Troy talked about his lifetime in San Diego, sampling many a Bali Hai concoction, and I waxed poetic about my first post-pregnancy drink—a Mai Tai, of course, from the longtime Shelter Island restaurant. This drink is legendary for being one of the strongest in town. As the Baumanns tell us, its recipe hasn’t changed since the 1950s and still packs a punch.

“We’ve sold over 3 million of these,” Larry says. “We had records going back to the ’60s, but we lost a decade. So, it’s probably even more.” The drink is almost five shots of rum with a splash of syrup, triple sec, and sour mix—no juice, no fluff. It’s a straight-up homage to the old-school tiki cocktails that once ruled the Pacific coast and have made a comeback in recent years.

The Baumanns also dig into Bali Hai’s origins, explaining how Shelter Island was once a sandbar that became a post-World War II playground, with a city mandate requiring all new buildings to adopt Polynesian architecture. “That doesn’t exist anymore, that mandate, but that’s how it started,” Larry explains.

Bali Hai, once a San Diego Magazine cover star in 1956, wasn’t always called as such. It started as Christian’s Hut, a nod to the Mutiny on the Bounty film and its romanticized vision of the South Pacific. But Tom Ham, a savvy accountant who decided taxes weren’t for him, saw an opportunity. 

San Diego restaurant Bali Hai family
Courtesy of Bali Hai

He bought the struggling restaurant and transformed it into Bali Hai, naming it after the famous song from South Pacific. From there, the restaurant took off, riding the wave of tiki culture. Ham’s daughter, Suzie, married Larry, who had just returned to San Diego from Vietnam, and they became the Baumanns. Their son, Tommy, and other family members have since joined the family business.

The Baumanns also share the trials and triumphs of running a family enterprise in an ever-changing industry with ever-crunching economics. Bali Hai has seen it all—from Hollywood types in the ’60s to generations of locals who make it their go-to spot for weddings, celebrations, and endless tales of misbehaving and triumphant celebrating on account of those famous Mai Tais.

“Every day someone comes in and says, ‘I’ve lived here for years and didn’t even know this was here.’ It’s a hidden gem, but also not so hidden,” Tommy says. Bali Hai is a relic of tiki’s golden era and a still-thriving piece of the city’s food and drink scene—a rare gem of a spot that has stayed mostly the same over time and remains iconic and crowded.

Tune in to hear more stories from the Baumanns, and remember, two Mai Tais are the limit. Trust me, that’s all you’ll need.

By Jackie Bryant

Jackie is San Diego Magazine's content strategist. Prior to that, she was its managing editor. Before her SDM career, she was a long-time freelance journalist covering cannabis, food/restaurants, travel, labor, wine, spirits, arts & culture, design, and other topics. Her work has been selected twice for Best American Travel Writing, and she has won a variety of national and local awards for her writing and reporting.

Share this post

LATEST EPISODES

Podcast

Kitchens for Good Tackles Food Waste & Empowers Student ...

Kitchens for Good Tackles Food Waste & Empowers Student Chefs

Listen now

Podcast

How The Mental Bar Became Encanto’s Third Place

Listen now

Podcast

Hidden Foods Co. is Cracking the Code for Picky Eaters

Listen now

Podcast

The San Diego Nonprofit Saving the World with Stoves

Listen now

Podcast

How Sam The Cooking Guy Won the Internet

Listen now

Podcast

Stella Jean's Secret Sauce Is Its Milk

Listen now

Podcast

Jimbo’s Naturally Celebrates 40 Years of Supporting Local ...

Jimbo’s Naturally Celebrates 40 Years of Supporting Local Farms & Businesses

Listen now

Podcast

Lia's Lumpia Fuses Filipino Cooking with Black Soul Food

Listen now

Podcast

Little Lion’s Chef Learned Everything from Her Grandparent...

Little Lion’s Chef Learned Everything from Her Grandparents

Listen now

Podcast

Actor Martin Short Becomes Mayor of a Food-Obsessed Town

Listen now

Podcast

San Diego’s Best Beer Isn't an IPA

Listen now

Podcast

Javier Plascencia Talks Michelin Stars & Caesar Salad's ...

Javier Plascencia Talks Michelin Stars & Caesar Salad's 100th

Listen now

Podcast

All the Best Eats at the San Diego County Fair

Listen now

Podcast

Cardellino Owner Brad Wise on Truffles, Caviar & Butcher...

Cardellino Owner Brad Wise on Truffles, Caviar & Butchering

Listen now

Podcast

San Diego's King of Produce

Listen now

Podcast

Is this San Diego's Most Picturesque Rooftop Restaurant?

Listen now

Podcast

Trying Petco Park's Best Food with Don and Mud

Listen now

Podcast

SD’s Secret Sommelier Weapon is at North Park’s Black Ra...

SD’s Secret Sommelier Weapon is at North Park’s Black Radish

Listen now

Podcast

Radio Host Chris Cantore & Chef Tyler Mars Launch New Po...

Radio Host Chris Cantore & Chef Tyler Mars Launch New Pop-Up

Listen now

Podcast

Fast Food Secrets With Jordan Howlett

Listen now

Podcast

Feeding San Diego Rescues 1.2M Pounds of Food a Month 

Listen now

Podcast

Making Wishes Come True With Chef William Eick

Listen now

Podcast

The Beach Boys’ Mike Love Puts Us in a Kokomo State of Min...

The Beach Boys’ Mike Love Puts Us in a Kokomo State of Mind

Listen now

Podcast

Lighting Up the Gaslamp 

Listen now

Contact Us

1230 Columbia Street, Suite 800,

San Diego, CA