Ready to know more about San Diego?

Subscribe

Sobremesa Closes, Making Way for a New Italian Restaurant in San Diego

The team behind Aromi Italian Cuisine and Trattoria da Sofia is transforming the San Carlos space into Trattoria Ciccio

Sobremesa Closes, Making Way for a New Italian Restaurant in San Diego
Courtesy of Trattoria Ciccio

Investing money in an industry with an exceptionally high rate of closure is not for the faint of heart, no matter if it’s your first restaurant or fifteenth. Despite the risks, it seems like something Andrea Carbonaro can’t seem to avoid.

The native Sicilian first put down roots in the San Diego restaurant scene in 2023 with Aromi Italian Cuisine in La Mesa, followed by Trattoria da Sofia and Pizza by Aromi in 2024. All lean into the homey trattoria vibe, offering comfort dishes like Caprese salads, arancini, cacio e pepe, and pollo parmigiana in family-friendly, laid-back space meant to feel like home. 

That approach worked—in fact, it worked so well he thought he’d spread his wings a bit and go in a different direction when he opened Sobremesa in 2025. With the help of a Michelin star-level chef and a familial ownership team that included his brother Dario and their cousins Mariano Liga and Francesco Mancino, Sobremesa aspired to be a Latin American-inspired, high-end destination in the San Carlos neighborhood. It was a big swing and proved to be an unfortunate miss (Sobremesa quietly closed this month). Ditto for the fast-casual concept Carbonaro’s on the SDSU campus. (It turns out only having a built-in student customer base for part of the year makes it hard for a non-chain restaurant to turn a profit.)

Undeterred, Carbonaro and his family partners are going back to their area of expertise. The 5,000-square-foot former home of Sobremesa has gone through a complete Sicilian overhaul, trading a Southwest-inspired desert motif for the traditional trattoria vibe complete with red-and-white striped awnings, olive branch accents, and a full-sized fountain in the middle of the dining room. The new iteration, Trattoria Ciccio, opens November 27.

(Don’t confuse it with Ciccio Osteria in Barrio Logan, which is run by chef/owner Mario Cassineri. In this case, “Ciccio” is a common nickname for Francesco, who will be the co-owner and chef at Trattoria Ciccio.)

Courtesy of Trattoria Ciccio

Carbonaro says he hopes to continue opening more trattoria-style restaurants across San Diego (hinting at, but not confirming any future plans). Similar to Trattoria da Sofia, Trattoria Ciccio’s menu will feature comforting pastas like spicy vodka pasta, gnocchi cacio e pepe, and braised beef ragù lasagna, as well as shareables like fiori di zucca (zucchini blossoms stuffed with basil ricotta and topped with spicy apricot jam) and garlic knots. Pinsas, or Roman-style flatbread pizzas, will come in classic flavors like margherita and prosciutto, and heartier entrees like brasato (a Northern Italian dish of beef slow-braised in red wine) will round out the Sicilian-inspired menu.

All his restaurants are designed to be especially kid-friendly—a must for neighborhood joints, he says. “We’re going to have a kid’s area in this trattoria, a little room with a bunch of games for kids and everything. So when families have dinner, they can leave the kids playing,” he explains. At the risk of sounding too Olive Garden-y, he wants your family to feel like his family. And by the sound of it, plenty of his own family will be there to make sure his vision comes to life. 

Trattoria Ciccio opens at 8622 Lake Murray Blvd. on Friday, November 27. Initial operating hours will be 3 p.m. to 9:30 p.m. daily, with happy hour running 3 p.m. to 5 p.m. Sunday through Thursday (subject to change). 

San Diego Restaurant News & Food Events

Beth’s Bites

  • Mr. Moto Pizza definitely understood the assignment—based on the hype surrounding today’s Grand Theft Auto 6 release, there are going to be hundreds, if not thousands of rabid racing and carjacking fans glued to their monitors for the foreseeable future. From now until 8 p.m. on Sunday, November 22, all locations of the local pizza joint are offering a “buy a pepperoni pizza, get a free cheese pizza” promotion with code GTA6 at checkout. Nicely done, Mr. Moto. May all your video gamer goals come true. 
  • Will they or won’t they? Roscoe’s Chicken & Waffles has already kept us waiting for years, and now another iconic LA dining dynasty is making big promises with conspicuously absent timeframes. Admittedly, Randy’s Donuts is open in Chula Vista and Mission Valley, but who knows when La Jolla and Otay Mesa will get their donuts going? La Jolla’s not exactly hurting for morning delights, but still. Give the people their donuts!
  • If you can’t quite make it until Trattoria Ciccio opens its doors, Solare Ristorante in Liberty Station just refreshed its menu with new antipastis including Sformato di Funghi Porcini (a savory flan), updated main courses like Orecchiette con Salsiccia e Cime di Rapa (pasta with Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, pecorino, garlic, chile pepper, and housemade herb bread crisps), and sweets like seasonal gelatos and sorbettos. Grab a bite before a show at the Cygnet Theater, and be sure to save room for the pumpkin panna cotta (or so I’m told).

Listen Now: The Latest in San Diego’s Food and Drink Scene

Have breaking news, exciting scoops, or great stories about new San Diego restaurants or the city’s food scene? Send your pitches to [email protected].

Beth Demmon

About Beth Demmon

Beth Demmon is an award-winning writer and podcaster whose work regularly appears in national outlets and San Diego Magazine. Her first book, The Beer Lover's Guide to Cider, is now available. Find out more on bethdemmon.com.

Eat Like a Local (Who Knows a Guy).

Restaurant news, culinary storytelling, and Troy Johnson’s sharp takes delivered straight to your inbox twice a month.

Close the CTA

Contact Us

1230 Columbia Street, Suite 800,

San Diego, CA